When looking to buy a gold chain, the question of whether to choose a solid or hollow chain often arises, but what exactly does that mean? How do you identify them, and what differentiates them?
In this article, we will explain what a solid chain is, what a hollow chain is, their advantages and disadvantages, how they are made, and most importantly, how to tell the difference between the two.
Table of Contents:
- Different Types of Gold Chains
- Advantages and Disadvantages of Each
- How are They Made?
- How to Tell the Difference Between a Solid and Hollow Gold Chain?
- Summary
- Mistakes to Avoid
1. Different Types of Gold Chains
As we've seen, there are two types of chains: solid and hollow. A filed curb chain, for example, can be either solid or hollow, but what's the difference?
1) a. What is a Solid Gold Chain?
A solid gold chain is a chain composed entirely of gold. Each link of the chain is full, filled with gold, meaning no empty space is present inside the chain. This is why it is called a "solid chain."
1) b. What is a Hollow Gold Chain?
A hollow gold chain is also made of gold, but this time, the links are manufactured with a thin layer of gold, which forms an empty structure inside each link. Again, the name "hollow chain" is explained by the presence of light space in the links.
2. Advantages and Disadvantages of Each
Each chain is different, and each chain has its specificities, including advantages and disadvantages. We will look at these advantages and disadvantages for solid and hollow chains.
Note that this can vary depending on the chain's links, such as filed curb, Figaro, horse, etc. Therefore, we will discuss the advantages and disadvantages in general here.
2) a. Advantages and Disadvantages of a Solid Chain.
Advantages:
- Very strong and resistant chain
- Long lifespan
- Higher intrinsic value (because it contains more gold)
Disadvantages:
- Higher price
- Heavier weight
2) b. Advantages and Disadvantages of a Hollow Chain.
Advantages:
- Lighter
- Lower price
- Better feel (more comfortable)
Disadvantages:
- More fragile
- Can deform or crush if not properly maintained
- Complex or even impossible repairs
3. How are They Made?
After looking at the advantages and disadvantages, the question of how these chains are made instinctively arises. After discussing what they contain, it is important to talk about a major element that constitutes them: their manufacture, which can vary and be completely different depending on the chain.
3) a. How is a Solid Chain Made?
The manufacturing of a solid gold chain relies on precision work specific to jewelry making.
The links are made from solid 18-karat gold wire, which is assembled and then individually soldered, creating a strong and robust structure.
This process results in a dense gold chain with no empty space inside the links, offering increased long-term durability and extreme resistance to wear, making it a reliable piece of jewelry for daily wear.
3) b. How is a Hollow Chain Made?
The manufacturing of a hollow gold chain is quite different from that of a solid one.
The chain is first made from a thin copper mandrel (a mold) which is then covered with a thin layer of gold. Once everything is assembled and formed, the chain is immersed in an acid that dissolves the copper, leaving only the gold. The dissolved copper then creates an empty space inside the gold chain.
This process results in a chain that is visually similar to a solid chain but lighter and much more affordable.
With minimal care and depending on the width of the links, this chain can last a long time and be worn daily.
4. How to Tell the Difference Between a Solid and Hollow Gold Chain?
Now that we have seen what these two types of chains are, what their advantages and disadvantages are, and how they are made, we will answer the initial question of this article: how to differentiate them?
As we saw earlier, each chain has its own specificities: the solid one is denser per meter and more expensive, while the hollow one is less dense per meter but more affordable.
Now, to differentiate them with the naked eye, it's almost impossible, except for the most experienced; for an average person, it's impossible.
The methods we can suggest are as follows:
- Weight: For the same size, a solid gold chain will be heavier than a hollow gold chain.
- Feel: For the solid chain, the feel is important because the solid chain is denser and more rigid than the hollow chain, and you can feel it, whereas the hollow chain is more flexible, giving the impression of being almost soft.
- Price: As we've seen, the solid chain is often more expensive because it is denser and contains more 18-karat gold than the hollow gold chain.
In Summary
Choosing between a solid and hollow chain depends on your priorities and budget:
- Solid chain: Longevity and investment
- Hollow chain: Budget and density
Mistakes to Avoid
Even when taking into account all the advice mentioned above, a mistake can still happen. For example, if a 45cm chain weighs 4g more than another 45cm chain, it's not necessarily because the heavier chain is solid; don't confuse light with hollow.
Indeed, a 50cm solid chain can be lighter than a 50cm hollow chain if, for example, its links are 2mm and those of the hollow chain are 5mm. In that case, the hollow one will inevitably be heavier, but not denser.
Similarly for the price, a solid chain can be cheaper than a hollow chain because, let's not forget, the manufacturing steps are different. A solid chain requires gold wire or a mold (and of course, craftsmanship), unlike a hollow chain, which requires copper and acid to create the empty space. There is also another method, using very thin gold sheets, where the price can also be higher because it takes longer to produce.
Finally, a common mistake many people make is relying on the size of the chain.
A large gold chain does not necessarily mean it is solid. Take for example curb chains, lentil chains, or the most popular in street fashion, Cuban link chains; these are chains that are visually large and impressive, giving the impression that they are dense and heavy, yet they are often hollow, less dense and heavy than one might imagine.
Need advice on choosing your gold chain?
If you would like more information, please do not hesitate to contact us via the form below or via our phone number or email address.
contact@bijouterie-or-gemmes.com
We remain at your disposal for any information.
